“Sunna” of Western Scholars on the Authenticiy of the Document of Medina: What’s So Special About it?

Authors : Fatma KIZIL

Pages : 48-66

Doi:10.47169/samer.1290134

View : 134 | Download : 71

Publication Date : 2023-06-30

Article Type : Research Paper

Abstract :The aim of this article is to focus on the views of modern Western scholars regarding the authenticity of the Document of Medina and its unity in relation to its date and preservation, rather than on the debates over its content. The focus is on their rationale for defending its authenticity despite the limited number of aḥadīth they date back to the first Islamic century. Additionally, considering the fact that many other reports with the characteristics of the document are not considered authentic, the question is raised whether it is the “sunna” of their predecessors that is actually decisive, since the testimony has been considered authentic since Julies Wellhausen on the same grounds.
Keywords : Siyer, Medine Anayasası, Aykırılık İlkesi, Hadis, Tarihî Öz